+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 5 12345 LastLast
Results 1 to 16 of 77

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    160

    TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    HOW IS THE TRINITY EXPLAINED?

    Do you believe in the Trinity? Most people in Christendom do. After all, it has been the central doctrine of the churches for centuries.

    In view of this, you would think that there could be no question about it. but there is, and lately even some of its devout supporters have added fuel to the controversy and opened up a whole new debate in this 21st Century about the Trinitarian Dogma and its validity.

    Why should a subject like this be of any more than passing interest? Because Jesus himself said: "Eternal life is this: to know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent."

    So our entire future hinges on our knowing the true nature of God, and that means getting to the root of the Trinity controversy. Therefore, why not examine it for yourself?-John 17:3, Catholic Jerusalem Bible (JB).

    Majority consensus may not always be right, right?


    The coming topic in this Blog will be of the most important essence in regards to this Article - TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM?

    Next: What Does The Bible Say About God and Jesus? Watch out for Chapter 11, Post number 11.




    Seeking Spiritual Truths From the Bible and HistoryHOW IS THE TRINITY EXPLAINED?
    Last edited by Emerantia; 12-18-2006 at 08:02 AM. Reason: afterthoughts
    "Hunger ye not after the unattainable, lest the hidden beauty and mysterious wonders of the 'real' life's simplicities that lay already within your grasp, should also elude you in your fruitless endeavors!'
    Extract from Quotable Sentiments by Emerantia Parnall-Gilbert Copyright C2005 All Rights Reserved

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Posts
    480

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Do you believe in the Trinity
    NO

    After all, it has been the central doctrine of the churches for centuries.
    Yes... but are u saying the longer soemthing is incorrect the more correct it becomes?

    In view of this, you would think that there could be no question about it.
    Screw god i love santa

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    939

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    In view of this, you would think that there could be no question about it. but there is, and lately even some of its devout supporters have added fuel to the controversy and opened up a whole new debate in this 21st Century about the Trinitarian Dogma and its validity.
    There are no "new" debates. Only old ones that are periodically rehashed. This one is no different.

  4. #4
    Born2Serve Guest

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    read 1John 5:7 KJV "Holy Trinity of God"

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    78

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by Born2Serve
    read 1John 5:7 KJV "Holy Trinity of God"
    It is necessary that you say "KJV" here because it is a text that was added to the Textus Receptus, the Greek text from which the KJV New Testament was translated. As it was added, it is not authentic, and thus show no Trinity.

    -Dave

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    160

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by dave-st
    It is necessary that you say "KJV" here because it is a text that was added to the Textus Receptus, the Greek text from which the KJV New Testament was translated. As it was added, it is not authentic, and thus show no Trinity.

    -Dave

    Hi Dave!

    Please tell me that you will stay around for a long time to come?
    :) You are well-read and we need someone like you. I do my best to try and get some of the readers (that verbalize these curious comments LOL) to take a look at my blog and hopefully will find some 'light' in there? You are almost (whether you realize it or not) some sort of 'guardian angel'. I know, I know that doesn't mean you accept my beliefs either, nevertheless I find your presence very comforting and I love your prompt answers. I would not ever have even thought about given an answer like that. All I can do is work with what I've learned over the years as a JW, and as a ex-Catholic have objectively been able to make my comparisons over time. To me it is all as clear and light as day that the Trinity does not exist. Wait till I get my blog completed on 'The Soul' topic. I wonder if I'll get well and truly clobbered by everyone. No doubt! But, the clergy Fathers have certainly done their job well by means of misleading indoctrinization.
    "Hunger ye not after the unattainable, lest the hidden beauty and mysterious wonders of the 'real' life's simplicities that lay already within your grasp, should also elude you in your fruitless endeavors!'
    Extract from Quotable Sentiments by Emerantia Parnall-Gilbert Copyright C2005 All Rights Reserved

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Posts
    26,286

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    speakin of santa!?hehe!i think the tim allen series of santa movies is GREAT!!anyone who denies the love/magic is just not a christian at heart!?hehe!!as to the trinity i have this to say about that!?GROUND ZERO!?hehe!!as real as it gets!?read the marble monument!?and....look to the jewish first text and the many ancient theorys of the cosmos!?the 1 makes 3 admits 6 and then follows by mechanical fallout/decree the material worlds!?hehe!!....just askin....

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    78

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by Emerantia
    Hi Dave!

    Please tell me that you will stay around for a long time to come?
    :) You are well-read and we need someone like you. I do my best to try and get some of the readers (that verbalize these curious comments LOL) to take a look at my blog and hopefully will find some 'light' in there? You are almost (whether you realize it or not) some sort of 'guardian angel'. I know, I know that doesn't mean you accept my beliefs either, nevertheless I find your presence very comforting and I love your prompt answers. I would not ever have even thought about given an answer like that. All I can do is work with what I've learned over the years as a JW, and as a ex-Catholic have objectively been able to make my comparisons over time. To me it is all as clear and light as day that the Trinity does not exist. Wait till I get my blog completed on 'The Soul' topic. I wonder if I'll get well and truly clobbered by everyone. No doubt! But, the clergy Fathers have certainly done their job well by means of misleading indoctrinization.

    Jehovah willing, I will be around for as long as I can be of use. I certainly am nothing close to a guardian angel, but I do try my best, with his help, to defend what is true and lead others to God and Christ.

    There is a lot to be said on the soul. The articles we have at http://www.scripturaltruths.com/soul might be of aid to you. Something I've noticed, which is there pointed out, is that many texts that people turn to in order to argue about the soul actually never even mention it! Of course some do, and in those cases context usually provides the necessary clarifications.

    -Dave

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,773

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by Emerantia
    HOW IS THE TRINITY EXPLAINED?

    Do you believe in the Trinity? Most people in Christendom do. After all, it has been the central doctrine of the churches for centuries.

    In view of this, you would think that there could be no question about it. but there is, and lately even some of its devout supporters have added fuel to the controversy and opened up a whole new debate in this 21st Century about the Trinitarian Dogma and its validity.

    Why should a subject like this be of any more than passing interest? Because Jesus himself said: "Eternal life is this: to know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent."

    So our entire future hinges on our knowing the true nature of God, and that means getting to the root of the Trinity controversy. Therefore, why not examine it for yourself?-John 17:3, Catholic Jerusalem Bible (JB).

    Majority consensus may not always be right, right?


    The coming topic in this Blog will be of the most important essence in regards to this Article - TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM?

    Next: What Does The Bible Say About God and Jesus? Watch out for Chapter 11, Post number 11.




    Seeking Spiritual Truths From the Bible and HistoryHOW IS THE TRINITY EXPLAINED?
    You have a misunderstanding, right off the bat.

    If the Godhead, the Tri-unity of three persons as one God....is one God....then how is that Godhead NOT a monotheistic God?

    God is a monotheistic God - there is one God, not three Gods.

    But let me ask you this;
    what think ye of Isaiah 44:6? Two Jehovah's?

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    464

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    We went through that one in Hebrew already, EK.

    And by the way, you do know how to count in Hebrew, yes? What's the word for 'one'?

    One more time--when 'echad' is used adjectivally in Hebrew, it means one and one alone, not a composite unity that makes up a 'one of something'.

    I know I'm not a Christian, but I really can't see the good coming over all this hairsplitting. Some of you see Jesus as part of the G-dhead, some see him as G-d's 'helper' for lack of a better term, whatever works for you, no?

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    78

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by EveryKnee
    You have a misunderstanding, right off the bat.

    If the Godhead, the Tri-unity of three persons as one God....is one God....then how is that Godhead NOT a monotheistic God?

    God is a monotheistic God - there is one God, not three Gods.

    But let me ask you this;
    what think ye of Isaiah 44:6? Two Jehovah's?
    Isaiah 44:6 is one Jehovah. This "his" is in reference to Israel, which is the nearest antecedent to the pronoun. Compare Isaiah 43:1.

    -Dave

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,773

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by ComplexKid
    We went through that one in Hebrew already, EK.

    And by the way, you do know how to count in Hebrew, yes? What's the word for 'one'?

    One more time--when 'echad' is used adjectivally in Hebrew, it means one and one alone, not a composite unity that makes up a 'one of something'.

    I know I'm not a Christian, but I really can't see the good coming over all this hairsplitting. Some of you see Jesus as part of the G-dhead, some see him as G-d's 'helper' for lack of a better term, whatever works for you, no?
    So Adam and Eve are as one flesh in the singular, as in they really are the same person, not two individuals rendered as one in the plural?

    And the parts of the Tabernacle - they were not individual pieces?

    Or is this a different Hebrew word than is used in Deut 6?

    Agreed that some see Jesus as a member of the Godhead. Those who say they represent God the Father as a "Sent One" are also correct.

    That Jesus is Jehovah (or He is not) is of incredible importance. The priority is of much greater weight than say, why He chose to dip His food.

    If Jesus was only a man, then how was it that all and every sin ever committed was placed on His body in such a way that God the Father had appeased His wrath?
    But that's the point; either that is true or it is not.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    78

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by EveryKnee
    So Adam and Eve are as one flesh in the singular, as in they really are the same person, not two individuals rendered as one in the plural?

    And the parts of the Tabernacle - they were not individual pieces?

    Or is this a different Hebrew word than is used in Deut 6?

    Agreed that some see Jesus as a member of the Godhead. Those who say they represent God the Father as a "Sent One" are also correct.

    That Jesus is Jehovah (or He is not) is of incredible importance. The priority is of much greater weight than say, why He chose to dip His food.

    If Jesus was only a man, then how was it that all and every sin ever committed was placed on His body in such a way that God the Father had appeased His wrath?
    But that's the point; either that is true or it is not.
    You seem to be confused, but it is really very simple. Echad = one. It is not a special word, but it is the word for the numeral. They are one flesh and it is compound because of the plural. The same principle applies to the English word. But when no plural is in view, one is one.

    As for how Jesus took on sin for us... it is because he was without sin. If he had sinned his sacrifice would have been worthless. Jesus is called "the last Adam," because he was a perfect man as Adam was before the fall. He took Adam's place, so as we all inherited sin from Adam, we all inherit life from Jesus.


    -Dave

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,773

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by dave-st
    Isaiah 44:6 is one Jehovah. This "his" is in reference to Israel, which is the nearest antecedent to the pronoun. Compare Isaiah 43:1.

    -Dave
    Isaiah 43:1
    But now thus says Jehovah who formed you, O Jacob;
    and who made you, O Israel;
    "Fear not, for I have redeemed you; I called you by
    your name; you are Mine."

    I think we agree that the "O Jacob" and the "O Israel" had their origins in Jehovah. So how does this compare to Isaiah 44:6?


    Israel is referred to as a woman in the Bible, and married to God (Isa 62:5, Jer, 3:8, Jer. 3:14, Hos. 1, Mal. 2:11, book of Revelation).

    And I don't see at all that the "his" as Israel in the text.

    So says Jehovah (who is the King of Israel), and His Redeemer (who is the Lord of hosts)...

    Nah, two persons.


    How about Isaiah 48? The person speaking from verses 12 to 22 is Jehovah.
    But it says in verse 16b and 17:

    ...From its being, I was there;
    and now the Lord Jehovah and His Spirit has sent Me..."


    Sounds like three people to me.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,773

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by dave-st
    You seem to be confused, but it is really very simple. Echad = one. It is not a special word, but it is the word for the numeral. They are one flesh and it is compound because of the plural. The same principle applies to the English word. But when no plural is in view, one is one.

    As for how Jesus took on sin for us... it is because he was without sin. If he had sinned his sacrifice would have been worthless. Jesus is called "the last Adam," because he was a perfect man as Adam was before the fall. He took Adam's place, so as we all inherited sin from Adam, we all inherit life from Jesus.


    -Dave
    No, you see there are two different words for the word "one" in Hebrew, 1) that denotes singular by itself and 2) a plurality of parts that are rendered as "one."
    I'm not saying that any of these two words are "special" but there are two different Hebrew words that is translated "one" in our english Bibles. CK had already commented that on another thread - he acknowledged that there are two different Hebrew words.[

    I'm not confused at all but I'm surprised that you don't see it with the examples given.

    Note, though, I was talking to CK; Christ had to be more than a man to take on the sins of the whole world. Can a man lay down his life and take it up again? Christ was more than a man.

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    78

    Re: TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM - Should You Believe It?

    Quote Originally Posted by EveryKnee
    Isaiah 43:1
    But now thus says Jehovah who formed you, O Jacob;
    and who made you, O Israel;
    "Fear not, for I have redeemed you; I called you by
    your name; you are Mine."

    I think we agree that the "O Jacob" and the "O Israel" had their origins in Jehovah. So how does this compare to Isaiah 44:6?


    Israel is referred to as a woman in the Bible, and married to God (Isa 62:5, Jer, 3:8, Jer. 3:14, Hos. 1, Mal. 2:11, book of Revelation).

    And I don't see at all that the "his" as Israel in the text.

    So says Jehovah (who is the King of Israel), and His Redeemer (who is the Lord of hosts)...

    Nah, two persons.


    How about Isaiah 48? The person speaking from verses 12 to 22 is Jehovah.
    But it says in verse 16b and 17:

    ...From its being, I was there;
    and now the Lord Jehovah and His Spirit has sent Me..."


    Sounds like three people to me.

    Actually Israel is referred to as a him repeatedly in Scripture. (cf. Jer. 2:14) You might want to check your own Trinitarian Bible commentators, as they regularly disagree with you.

    For example, Gill writes: "and his Redeemer, the Lord of hosts; who redeemed Israel out of Egypt, from the house of bondage, and would again redeem them from the Babylonish captivity"

    Barnes and Jamieson, Fauscett and Brown both cross reference this to Isaiah 43:1.

    The NIV and Holman Bible both translate this in a way that makes perfectly clear, showing Israel to be the one being redeemed, saying: "Israel's King and Redeemer." The Interpreter's Commentary says the same.

    For Isaiah 48, I'd again suggest you do some digging. First, "his Spirit" is not a statement of a person. Nobody speaks of a person's spirit as a person in itself. Second, the one being sent is the prophet. Barnes states: "There is evidently a change in the speaker here. In the former part of the verse, it is God who is the speaker. But here it is he who is sent to bear the message... The scope of the passage demands, as it seems to me, that it should be referred to the prophet himself."

    -Dave

Similar Threads

  1. The trinity is a pagan god.
    By Cnance in forum Religious Scams
    Replies: 277
    Last Post: 02-15-2019, 12:22 PM
  2. Trinity Blue Inc.
    By dsmesc in forum Internet Scams
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 07-02-2016, 02:00 PM
  3. Is the trinity really a trinity?
    By BibleCode in forum Religious Scams
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 07-17-2009, 01:43 AM
  4. TRINITY OR MONOTHEISM? What Does the Bible Teach?
    By Emerantia in forum Religious Scams
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-05-2007, 12:09 PM
  5. Trinity Financial?
    By WolfMaiden in forum Business Scams
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 08-08-2006, 10:52 AM

Tags for this Thread

Add / Edit Tags
000, account, accurate, addition, address, admit, admitted, advanced, agen, aka, ale, ame, another, appears, appointment, article, attempts, aus, australia, authentic, authorized, authors, avoid, based, ben, bible, bit, blood, body, books, bright, brown, called, care, carefully, catholic, caught, central, cer, chapters, charles, check, chris, close, closes, college, coming, comments, commissioned, communication, community, counting, crack, credible, crisis, critical, dan, dark, darkness, david, day, dead, declared, deep, defended, deserve, destroyed, destruction, details, doesn, don, dont, door, drew, duality, due, dying, easy, egypt, eme, error, examples, explained, express, extreme, faithful, fall, families, fee, fla, flat, fled, focus, fool, foundation, fuel, future, gen, generation, gli, god, ground, handed, hands, head, healing, hearts, heaven, hell, hey, hot, house, huma, human, ian, important, include, incredible, individuals, influence, inheritance, inherited, interest, isn, jerusalem, john, joke, judge, land, large, late, letters, life, line, lis, lisa, listen, living, local, lol, long, longer, los, loves, lying, martin, mea, memories, middle, million, mind, myth, named, nature, nope, onli, org, par, part, passage, paul, pen, person, personal, play, poison, pos, post, pressed, prime, proof, prophet, public, punish, qualified, question, real, reality, reason, reasonable, reasons, record, reincarnation, reliable, removed, rendered, rendition, respect, respond, rev, rock, rome, roo, room, rope, roy, sacred, salvation, scrivener, sec, sen, serve, service, short, show, simply, sir, site, skin, slam, son, sons, soo, source, sources, specifically, start, states, stories, strength, striking, student, style, success, sun, take a look, taken, talking, temple, thread, tim, times, tme, totally, tradition, truth, twist, url, usa, vatican, version, vice, view, vince, wanted, watson, weird, win, won, word, words, work, working, writes, writing, wrote, www, young

View Tag Cloud

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may post new threads
  • You may post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may edit your posts
  •